Skip to content

625 May Joe Street, St Simons Island, GA 31522


5 Beds

4 Full baths

4390 SqFt

Closed

Tucked on a quiet street in the heart of the Village, this warm and inviting St. Simons retreat blends walkability, privacy, and resort style living on a rare 0.37 acre lot. Just a short stroll from the pier, restaurants, playground, library, parks, pickleball courts and beach, the home offers the ideal coastal lifestyle with every convenience close at hand. The main residence features approximately 3600 SQ FT of thoughtfully updated living space, including generous gathering areas, a bright kitchen, and a serene primary suite. Large windows frame views of the pool and landscaped grounds, creating a seamless connection between indoor and outdoor living. A separate 800 SQ FT garage apartment with its own entrance provides exceptional flexibility perfect for guests, extended family, a private office or income potential. Outside, the private backyard feels like a personal resort, complete with a sparkling pool, flagstone accents, and multiple areas for lounging and entertaining. The lot’s size and mature landscaping offer a sense of space rarely found in the Village. Beautifully maintained with major renovations in 2005 and 2019, this home combines timeless character with modern comfort in one of St. Simons Island’s most sought after walkable neighborhoods. Click here for a full video of the property. https://youtu.be/_3WCf3m5Hbg

0 upcoming open houses

Property Details
Price$2,100,000
Close Price$1,950,000
Bedrooms5
Full Baths4
Half Baths0
Property StyleCottage,Traditional
Lot Size,,,
Lot Size Area0.37
Lot Size Area UnitsAcres
Acres0.37
Land TenureFee Simple
Property TypeResidential
Sub typeSingleFamilyResidence
MLS Sub typeSingle Family Residence
FeaturesAttic,Breakfast Bar,Breakfast Area,Crown Molding,Kitchen Island,Pantry,Pull Down Attic Stairs,Permanent Attic Stairs,Ceiling Fan(s),Fireplace,Cable TV
Exterior FeaturesPorch,Paved Driveway
Year Built1953
Fireplaces2
SubdivisionSt Simons Park
ViewOther,Residential
RoofAsphalt
HeatingElectric,Heat Pump
FoundationCrawlspace,Slab
Lot DescriptionLandscaped,Level,Private
Laundry FeaturesOther
Pool featuresIn Ground,Pool
Parking DescriptionDriveway,Garage Door Opener,Paved
Parking Spaces6
Garage spaces2
Geographic Data
DirectionsHeading east on Demere towards Ocean Blvd, take right on to May Joe St. Home on right. Look for sign.
CountyGlynn
Market AreaS1: South SSI
Address Information
Address625 May Joe Street, St Simons Island, GA 31522
Postal Code31522
CitySt Simons Island
StateGA
CountryUnited States
Listing Information
Listing OfficeEngel & Volkers Golden Isles
Listing Office Phone912-634-0595
Listing Office Emailjohn.hallman@engelvoelkers.com
Listing AgentJohn Hallman
Listing Agent Phone912-634-0595
Virtual Tour Urlhttps://my.matterport.com/show/?m=aH3R1zoEkyQ
School Information
Elementary SchoolSt. Simons
Middle SchoolGlynn Middle
High SchoolGlynn Academy
MLS Information
Days on market216
MLS StatusClosed
Listing DateOct 2, 2025
Listing Last ModifiedMay 6, 2026
Tax ID0404602
Tax Year2025
Tax Annual Amount3547
MLS AreaS1: South SSI
MLS #1657034

Forward this listing

Your Name

Your Email (required)

Recipient Name

Recipient Email(required)

Mortgage Calculator

List Price
Mortgage Rate (%)
Down Payment
Mortgage Term (Yrs.)
Loan Amount
Total Interest
No. of Payments
Monthly Payment


This information is believed to be accurate, but without any warranty.

Scroll To Top